Ben Thornley was a professional footballer who played for the same Manchester United youth team as the fabled Class of ’92 – David Beckham, Ryan Giggs, Paul Scholes, Gary Neville etc.
With Beckham-esque looks and Giggs-esque skill, Thornley was tipped for greatness by many. However, a horror tackle in a reserve game, just weeks after his first team debut, severely damaged his knee and ultimately his chances of making it to the very top. Thornley recovered and played for a number of years but was never able to fulfill his vast potential.
Tackled tells the story of Thornley’s life in football. The book jumps back and forward between the time before his injury and the time afterwards. The earlier periods are told through many voices including his family members the likes of Beckham, Giggs, Scholes etc. The later periods are told in a more orthodox autobiographical style.
The format works very well. The book feels really genuine and the style captures the interaction among friends and family really well. There is a lot of humour in the banter among friends and many of the anecdotes may not have been told to a more traditional biographer.
Thornley is pretty open about his own failings in particular his fondness for booze and his constant cheating on his partners. At times the stories are a bit laddish – and Thornley seems to relish the retelling of some of his less than polite behaviour. However, the telling of his off-field life while a player is necessary to fully appreciate how difficult it must have been to come to terms with his reduced status in the game.
The attitude to booze is interesting. Thornley is open about enjoying a drink but there isn’t a close look at whether he might have had addiction issues – overall the treatment of booze leans more to the “pints are great fun” direction (which they are) than the role booze likely played in hampering Ben to do as well as he possibly could post injury. I’m conscious I’ve just hit a year without a drink so my attention naturally more drawn to boozy stories.
Football wise, the book contains some interesting insights into the English game of the late 90’s. In particular Thornley was fairly scathing of the short-lived Lilleshall model which saw the FA try to mimic the French Bluefontaine academy with very little success. Most of all, it gives quite a lot of insight into the Man Utd set up at the time, with a particular focus on the youth coach Eric Harrison.
Thornley is not the first or last footballer to have his potential cut down by injury. Thornley’s association to the famous Class of ’92 – that remarkable generation of players to come through the ranks at Man Utd at the same time – helps add some glamour and celebrity to the story. There is something about the fact that the players have developed their own group brand annoys me no end, but it’s good to see one the less successful members able to cash in on it.
You might find yourself wondering why bother to read an autobiography by a player whose career highlight is winning an underage tournament. But any sports book is never solely about the results on the pitch – Thornley shows a different side of the game, the side of potential unfulfilled, of hopes dashed and the challenges of nonetheless building a life. It is a very honest and candid account of the life of the superstar that never was.
Thornley comes across as a likeable guy (unless you were his ex girlfriend) who has matured and come to appreciate what he achieved rather than what he didn’t. Overall Tackled is an enjoyable read and one that Man Utd fans in particular would enjoy.